Face to Face Games: Locations, Buylist, Store Guide

If you’ve been hunting for Magic: The Gathering singles, Pokémon cards, or Yu-Gi-Oh packs in Canada, chances are someone has pointed you toward Face to Face Games. The Toronto-based retailer has built a reputation over two decades as a go-to spot for traders and players alike — and with a nationwide buylist program and event tours spanning coast to coast, the name keeps surfacing in card-shopping conversations across the community. This guide walks through what the store actually offers, where to find it, how its buylist works, and whether it’s the right fit for your next trade.

The key facts at a glance include 14,378 Facebook likes, 1.48K YouTube subscribers, a Toronto flagship location, a Verdun, QC secondary location, and a 30% trade bonus on store credit.

Facebook Likes: 14,378 · YouTube Subscribers: 1.48K · Primary Location: Toronto · Secondary Location: Verdun, QC · Trade Bonus: 30%

The contact and social details for Face to Face Games include website, social media handles, and TCG specialty focus.

Face to face games locations

Face to Face Games operates a flagship store in Toronto and maintains a presence in Quebec through its Verdun location, with events also drawing players to Montréal. The retailer also brings its buylist and inventory to cities across Canada via the F2F Tour, a traveling event series that stops in Ottawa, Calgary, Quebec City, Nanaimo, and Regina, among other locations.

Toronto store

The Toronto flagship sits just outside Greenwood Station, placing it in the eastern part of the city within walking distance of the subway line. The store stocks a deep selection of trading card games including Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, and Pokémon, along with board games and hobby supplies. BlogTO ranked it among the top board game stores in the city back in 2013, noting it as one of the best-stocked hobby shops near Greenwood Station.

Montréal and Verdun details

The Quebec presence centers on Verdun, a borough of Montréal. Rather than a full retail storefront, Face to Face Games runs events and buylist drop-offs in the area. For players in the greater Montréal region, the F2F Tour provides regular opportunities to access the retailer’s inventory and sell cards in person.

Face to face games buylist

The buylist program is one of Face to Face Games’ most distinctive features. Unlike many retailers that only buy in-store, F2F lets you assess your cards online before bringing them in, creating a streamlined process that seasoned traders appreciate.

Trade bonus details

The retailer offers 30% trade bonus on store credit when you sell via the buylist. That means if your cards are valued at $100 in cash value, you’ll receive $130 in store credit — a meaningful incentive if you’re planning to turn that credit into new singles or sealed product. The bonus applies to both singles and sealed Magic: The Gathering products submitted through the system.

How to sell cards

The process works in two steps. First, you download the Canadian-specific buylist from F2F Buylist, which is available as both PDF and CSV. You can search for your cards, see current buy prices, and prepare your submission. Then, you bring the cards to the store in person, or drop them off at one of the scheduled F2F Tour events across Canada. Selling options include the Sit Down Buy service for larger collections, Express Selling for submissions under 50 cards, and Drop Off at events or retail locations.

Face to face games store

Beyond the buylist, Face to Face Games functions as a full-service hobby retailer with physical inventory across multiple trading card game categories.

Products sold

The store carries all three major TCGs: Magic: The Gathering, Yu-Gi-Oh, and Pokémon. Singles availability tends to be deepest for MTG, which aligns with the retailer’s positioning as Canada’s largest Magic retailer. Sealed product, accessories, and board games also appear on shelves. The online store extends the physical inventory beyond what’s immediately on hand, with worldwide shipping available.

Shipping info

Face to Face Games ships internationally, not just within Canada. Domestic Canadian orders qualify for free shipping once they exceed the order threshold listed on the site. The retailer’s official site confirms worldwide shipping availability, making it a viable option for buyers outside Canada who need specific singles or sealed product.

The shipping model positions Face to Face Games as a viable option for international buyers seeking specific TCG singles that may be harder to source abroad.

Face to Face Games Toronto

The Toronto location serves as the retailer’s primary hub, anchoring both the walk-in customer base and the regional event schedule.

Store address

The Toronto store sits just outside Greenwood Station on the subway line, making it accessible from downtown and the surrounding GTA. While a street address isn’t prominently displayed on the main site, the proximity to Greenwood Station is well-documented through community references and editorial coverage from blogTO.

In-person events

Face to Face Games operates as a Wizards of the Coast (WPN) partner, meaning it hosts sanctioned Magic: The Gathering events including Prerelease tournaments, Friday Night Magic, and larger competitive events. The F2F Tour events also frequently include competitive REL tournaments alongside the buylist services. This WPN status places the store on the map for players seeking officially sanctioned play.

Face to face Games support

Getting in touch with Face to Face Games is straightforward through digital channels, though phone support is not the primary method.

Contact methods

The retailer maintains an active website at Face to Face Games with an online contact form for inquiries. Social media channels including Facebook (FaceToFaceGames), YouTube (FacetoFaceGamesCanada), and Instagram (facetofacegames) provide additional touchpoints for customer service questions and community interaction. The YouTube channel alone has attracted 1.48K subscribers, indicating an engaged audience.

Customer service

Community feedback on Reddit threads consistently points to reliable service over the retailer’s two-decade history. A Reddit user summarized the general sentiment: “Definitely not a scam. I buy from F2F all the time… No issues with them in 2 decades.” That long-track record in a community-driven space suggests the retailer has maintained customer trust without major incidents.

“Definitely not a scam. I buy from F2F all the time… No issues with them in 2 decades.”

— Reddit community member, r/mtgfinance (referenced in community trust discussions)

“This games and hobby store is one of the best stocked in the city.”

— blogTO reviewer, 2013 Toronto board game store ranking

Community trust runs deep here. One Reddit user with two decades of purchasing history put it plainly: “No issues with them in 2 decades.” That track record, combined with WPN partnership and a dedicated buylist infrastructure, gives Face to Face Games credibility that newer or online-only retailers lack.

Meeplemart, another major Toronto store, stocks over 75,000 different board, card, and war games and features a pinball arcade, making it more of a general hobby destination compared to Face to Face Games’ TCG focus. Meeplemart competes on breadth; F2F competes on depth within the card game categories.

The Sword & Board in west-end Toronto positions itself as “the premier tabletop gaming store” for miniatures, TCGs, RPGs, and board games, also offering buy/sell services. The Sword & Board serves a similar buyer profile but from a different neighborhood — useful if you’re on the west side of the city and want to compare buylist offers.

For GTA-based players, comparing Face to Face Games against 401 Games — which operates locations at 431 Yonge Street in Toronto and 7700 Keele Street in Vaughan — is worth the extra trip. 401 Games carries a broad selection including sports cards and collector items, while F2F maintains a deeper MTG specialization.

What distinguishes Face to Face Games is the combination of the online buylist tool, the 30% store credit bonus, and the WPN-sanctioned event schedule. None of its Toronto competitors offer all three. Meeplemart leads on board game volume; 401 Games leads on location count; but when it comes to serious MTG trading, F2F holds the position that two decades of community trust have built.

Related reading: Toronto Blue Jays News · Toronto Maple Leafs Breaking News

Frequently asked questions